Saturday, February 21, 2009

Proposal: Self-kills? Unchangable? Why?

While suicide attacks are normally frowned upon by High Command, it doesn’t mean they should be any less suicidal (Vetoed by Amnistar)
Enacted by arthexis, Minister of Propaganda

Adminned at 23 Feb 2009 12:11:11 UTC

Change the text:

If a Soldier votes against his own proposal, that vote may not be changed. This is referred to as a Self-Kill.

in core rule 1.4 Voting to:

If a Soldier votes against his own proposal, this is referred to as a Self-Kill.

Comments

Clucky: he/him

21-02-2009 22:06:26 UTC

Part of it has to be the “The Soldier who proposed it has voted AGAINST it.” line in the fail clause. If you could un-SK it, then it might matter when an admin chooses to fail an SKed proposal or not. Plus, if you SK your proposal its your own fault. If you actually wanted it to pass, repropose. Allowing for un SKing simply allows for more loopholes.

against

Kevan: he/him

21-02-2009 22:15:46 UTC

against It’s pretty basic; the point is that people stop voting when you self-kill something.

If something gets a few FOR votes, then one “hey, guys, this is broken” AGAINST, then an apologetic self-kill, we don’t want the self-killer triumphantly changing his vote back to FOR a few hours before it times out.

Wakukee:

21-02-2009 22:56:50 UTC

against Even though it gives Qwaz an oppurtunity to destroy my proposals.

arthexis: he/him

21-02-2009 23:12:24 UTC

against

Devenger:

21-02-2009 23:16:12 UTC

against what Kevan said

Klisz:

22-02-2009 00:19:50 UTC

against  ironic self-kill per Clucky and Kevan.

Qwazukee:

22-02-2009 03:05:30 UTC

against

Igthorn:

22-02-2009 07:02:18 UTC

against

ais523:

22-02-2009 13:45:59 UTC

against

Klisz:

22-02-2009 23:21:38 UTC

General Amnistar, I recommend usage of the grenade.

Wakukee:

22-02-2009 23:37:20 UTC

I dont, there are huge amounts of againsts and the grednade will send col. damage through the roof!

Amnistar: he/him

23-02-2009 14:47:01 UTC

veto BOOOOOOOOOOOOM