Saturday, January 23, 2010

Proposal: Servants and gods part 2

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 25 Jan 2010 06:47:14 UTC

Change

Move to another room on any floor. As above, except this action may only be taken by the Detectives, the Murderers and the Servants, who all have a better knowledge of Cartlesham Manor.

in Rule 2.6 Lights to

Move to another room on another floor. As above, except this action may only be taken by the Detectives, the Murderers and the Servants, who all have a better knowledge of Cartlesham Manor. A Dark List may contain only one Move to another room on another floor action.

To make the murderes` job a bit harder and also create some “safe rooms”. This game needs more logic! My last post was not a proposal…

posted by Keba at 23 Jan 2010 21:47:13 UTC Comments (18)

Comments

There:

23-01-2010 21:53:39 UTC

against Takes away the point of allowing the murderers and detectives to move floors in the dark. If any of them aren’t servants, then it is a give away.

Roujo: he/him

23-01-2010 21:55:21 UTC

for =)

Roujo: he/him

23-01-2010 21:56:20 UTC

Although There has a point…

alethiophile:

23-01-2010 22:14:30 UTC

against

Keba:

23-01-2010 22:22:05 UTC

@ There: You are allowed to create a new Proposal, which tries to enact your wish!

But if you do not want to do so, I do: http://blognomic.com/archive/murderes_and_detectives_doesnt_know_cartlesham_manor/

PS: Who is wondering abouts alethiophile’s vote? ;)

alethiophile:

23-01-2010 22:28:43 UTC

Keba: Even if I was the murderer, could I take advantage of this right now? :P

ais523: Mastermind

23-01-2010 22:37:13 UTC

for Should hopefully mean that more tactics are involved in interfloor movement; there are powers floating around which would allow players to move back to the previous floor, or move other people between floors already, IIRC.

Anonyman:

23-01-2010 22:51:08 UTC

imperial

Kevan: he/him

23-01-2010 22:53:20 UTC

against Per There. Not sure I understand ais523’s point - we shouldn’t rely on powers to balance this, as the murderers and detectives could have taken any role.

redtara: they/them

23-01-2010 23:24:02 UTC

for Don’t like the free move anyway; it’s not fair to anyone who is /not/ a servant.

Darknight: he/him

23-01-2010 23:25:24 UTC

against

TrumanCapote:

24-01-2010 02:52:02 UTC

imperial

Oze:

24-01-2010 08:48:01 UTC

against

Purplebeard:

24-01-2010 13:28:37 UTC

against

Ornithopter:

24-01-2010 16:48:35 UTC

against
You could limit it to two floor moves to keep the ability to hit and run intact, but all that does is prevent people from moving to the attic from the basement or vice versa.

Excalabur:

25-01-2010 00:22:48 UTC

against

digibomber:

25-01-2010 04:09:32 UTC

against per there

Keba:

25-01-2010 14:18:19 UTC

tactical self kill.  against