Monday, June 22, 2009

Call for Judgment: Setting the Record Straight

Fails 0-8. - Qwazukee

Adminned at 26 Jun 2009 16:35:40 UTC

yuri_dragon_17, Qwazukee, and Clucky are considered never to have been Evacuees, and are Insiders.

Without ais here to guide us, there were several major misunderstandings on the part of all Contestants.

Comments

Ienpw III:

06-22-2009 15:58:57 UTC

for

omd:

06-22-2009 15:59:10 UTC

against

Qwazukee:

06-22-2009 15:59:44 UTC

for

Clucky:

06-22-2009 16:14:51 UTC

for

ais523:

06-22-2009 16:27:14 UTC

This CFJ depends on: would you rather play a nomic in which scams decide things, or in which the intent of the rules decide things? I’m inclined towards the second (for BlogNomic, it’s one of the things that makes it unique), but am interested in what other people will think.

Hix:

06-22-2009 16:47:42 UTC

...I’m concerned that this CfJ does not mention a time frame.  After all, CfJs can take effect up to 4 days after they are created, no?  So the effects of this CfJ could be totally ignoring whatever happens during that time.

Qwazukee:

06-22-2009 16:53:23 UTC

Shouldn’t be an issue, but we can Vote this down if it is.

Clucky:

06-22-2009 20:39:26 UTC

Hix—passing a CfJ fixing a change in favor of the spirit of the rules and then abusing that against the spirit of the rules is silly enough that I don’t think anyone is going to try it.

Darknight:

06-22-2009 21:08:27 UTC

i love when the watchers come out to help out. i’m not voting on this.

Clucky:

06-24-2009 17:42:29 UTC

against

Klisz:

06-24-2009 17:44:24 UTC

against

ais523:

06-24-2009 19:00:01 UTC

@Clucky: as for your reply to Hix, that’s the sort of trick I often try to pull off in nomic. BlogNomic seems like the wrong nomic for it, though.

Qwazukee:

06-24-2009 20:37:39 UTC

CoV against

Well, this would be pretty bad now.

ais523:

06-24-2009 20:49:20 UTC

against This’ll be stuck in the sidebar forever unless we all work together to fail it, and it won’t do anything now because yuri’s won anyway.

Amnistar:

06-25-2009 08:55:09 UTC

against

Qwazukee:

06-25-2009 08:59:10 UTC

yuri come vote against this.

Shem:

06-25-2009 10:09:38 UTC

against

Ienpw III:

06-26-2009 18:47:48 UTC

against