Monday, January 25, 2010

Proposal: Shhhh

Self-killed. -Ornithopter

Adminned at 26 Jan 2010 12:35:44 UTC

Create a new rule called “Deathly Quiet” with the following text:

A Guest is not allowed to create, or respond to, any posts that discusses which Guests may or may not be the Murderers or Detectives if their Status is currently Dead.

Add the following to the end of the function of the roles called “Vicar” and “Spiritualist”:

As a weekly action, the Vicar and/or the Spiritualist may make a story post asking two questions to one named Guest whose Status is currently Dead. The Guest can only answer with the following: Yes, No or the name of a Guest.

If half of all EVCs contain the word “Sush”, then disallow comments to be posted in any post made by a Guest whose Status is currently Dead that was made before this Proposal was enacted.

I think its abit unfair to have guests that are dead still be able to freely discuss who might be a murderer. This way they can channel their thoughts out without pulling a *I only died in the game, I can still talk* scam, more so if a VC comes up that centers on if the murderers kill everyone first.

posted by Darknight at 25 Jan 2010 05:28:43 UTC Comments (7)

Comments

Darknight: he/him

25-01-2010 05:58:08 UTC

Proposer for Sush

Wakukee:

25-01-2010 06:04:33 UTC

So dead people can’t vote?  against .
This is basically being force-idled. Plus they can always be in irc or pms…

Wakukee:

25-01-2010 06:05:55 UTC

Actually,  imperial , but only if I am sure that the optional part will not pass.

Rodlen:

25-01-2010 08:22:39 UTC

for

Ornithopter:

25-01-2010 08:34:26 UTC

against
I agree with this in theory, but the new Deathly Quiet rule would be too narrow in scope to accomplish it’s goal, and I think limiting the dead to just “yes” and “no” is better, since it eliminates the obvious “Who do you think killed you?” that is what the proposal’s trying to eliminate in the first place. The EVCed clause is too broad in scope, and will disallow voting on anything Ienpw proposes before this passes.

Darknight: he/him

25-01-2010 09:24:04 UTC

oh bugger. well I’ll repropose this with the changes and drop the rider. I had intended to mark that they can still vote on proposals just not talk in story posts. against

Hix:

25-01-2010 14:29:11 UTC

(self-killed)