Monday, March 16, 2020

Proposal: Simplified Weights

Popular, 8-1. Josh

Adminned at 18 Mar 2020 10:40:15 UTC

In the rule “Auctions” replace “the highest bid of Money plus Power” with “the highest bid of Money plus Adjusted Power, which is the Power bid multiplied by the Weighted Power Factor,”

After “Updating the Estates of the Winners to list the Items that they have won” add a new step “Adjust the Weighted Power Factor in accordance to the Weighted Power Factor sub rule”

Add a new sub rule to “Auctions” called “Weighted Power Factor” and give it the following text

The Weighted Power Factor is an rational value tracked on the Nobleman page of the wiki with a default value of one.

To Adjust the Weighted Power Factor, Louis XIV adds the total amount of Debt bid by all Noblemen in the auction they are resolving (D) and compares it to the total Weighted Power Factor bid by all Noblemen in the same auction (P)

If D at least twice the value of P, the Weighted Power Factor is increased by 0.2. Otherwise, if D is at least 125% the value of P, the Power Weighted Factor is increased by 0.1
If P at least twice the value of D, the Weighted Power Factor is reduced by 0.2. Otherwise, if P is at least 125% the value of D, the Power Weighted Factor is reduced by 0.1

 

I don’t think we need to weight prestige. Prestige can be a currency that is earned rather than one that is spent. And if we aren’t weighting prestige, we don’t need separate weights for Debt and Power we can just have one weight for Power that goes up if people bid a lot of debt and goes down if instead people are bidding power until an equilibrium point is reached

Comments

Josh: Observer he/they

16-03-2020 17:50:34 UTC

for

Lulu: she/her

16-03-2020 19:16:56 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

16-03-2020 19:24:31 UTC

for

card:

16-03-2020 19:37:33 UTC

imperial

naught:

16-03-2020 20:00:49 UTC

for

TyGuy6:

16-03-2020 22:40:04 UTC

What is the “total Weighted Power Factor bid by all Noblemen”? Is it supposed to be the “total Adjusted Power bid by Noblemen”?

against I just don’t see the point of adjusting the weights (so slowly).

Clucky: he/him

17-03-2020 02:42:35 UTC

whoops I accidentally replaced that when I refactored what I was calling Weighted Power Factor. That should be Adjusted Power, but that can be fixed.

The point of adjusting the weights is that otherwise we might find that no one ever uses power because one debt is always worth more than one power. Its a multiplicative factor, so I don’t think its really that slow. If we find its still off and no one is using power we can always speed it up.

Brendan: he/him

17-03-2020 16:19:02 UTC

imperial

Kevan: he/him

17-03-2020 16:55:48 UTC

imperial