Friday, August 26, 2005

Call for Judgment: Smuggled items.

1-2. Timed Out.—Chronos

Adminned at 31 Aug 2005 07:16:37 UTC

Chronos Phareon says that Rodney doesn’t have either of eir Paints, because the same effect that sent Rodney to Gaol also activated the one that toke eir Paints. This doesn’t make much sense, as there are 3 effects. The last one gives the person who sent the Debitor to Gaol half the price of the Debitor’s items. Under Cronos’s interpitation, that would mean that that last one was activated too, but that wouldn’t make any sense under the current rules.

Vote FOR this CFJ if you think that the effects are seperate and didn’t trigger each other.

Vote AGAINST this CFJ if you don’t.

Should this CFJ pass then Rodney’s interpitation shall be considered correct, and eir actions legal.

posted by Call for Judgment at 26 Aug 2005 12:41:37 UTC Comments (5)

Comments

ChronosPhaenon:

26-08-2005 13:03:21 UTC

against From Proposal: Scooter loophole:

If, since the posting of this proposal, a player have had 4 or more Scooters at a given time, move e to Gaol as if they have had been in debt for 4 days, then set eir B$ to -1.

From <strong>Debtor’s Prison</strong, at the moment Rodney was moved to Gaol:

If a player has negative money for more than 4 days, then any other player may move them to Gaol and delete all Items in eir Item list and increase their B$ by half the current cost of the items if bought new, rounded down.

My interpretaion is that due to Debtor’s Prison, “If a player has negative money for more than 4 days” all the things listed in the rest of the paragraph happens. Proposal: Scoooter loophole says we had to “move [Rodney] to Gaol as if [e] have had been in debt for 4 days,”.

BTW, the name is PHAENON…

jamuraa:

26-08-2005 14:43:52 UTC

against

Rodney:

26-08-2005 17:26:34 UTC

But what about the last clause? That doesn’t make any sense.

ChronosPhaenon:

26-08-2005 17:39:40 UTC

the part about “and increase their B$ by half the current cost of the items if bought new, rounded down.”? It was done. Then your B$ got set to -1, as per the text “then set eir B$ to -1.”

The timing of the events was:
* Proposal: Scooter loophole was posted
* You used too many scooters.
* Proposal: Scooter loophole passed.
* You was moved to Gaol, as if you have had been in debt for 4 days (This triggered you losing all your non-existent properties and all of your Items, receiving half their value in B$)
* Your B$ was set to -1.

Rodney:

29-08-2005 00:38:50 UTC

for