Wednesday, May 31, 2017

Proposal: Sphinx should be able to play along as well

Self killed. Failed by card.

Adminned at 01 Jun 2017 15:52:59 UTC

Change “The Expedition Leader cannot publicly or privately reveal the Backgrounds of any Explorer unless instructed to do so by a rule.” to
“The Expedition Leader cannot publicly or privately reveal the Backgrounds of any Explorer unless instructed to do so by a rule. The Expedition Leader may claim, in private messages, what one or more of their Backgrounds are; these claims do not have to be the Expedition Leader’s actual Backgrounds.

What if the Expedition Leader wants to tell someone that they are a spy?

Comments

Kevan: he/him

31-05-2017 07:50:05 UTC

imperial

Madrid:

31-05-2017 09:58:59 UTC

Who? The Expedition Leader doesn’t have Backgrounds, per: “Each Explorer (which isn’t the Expedition Leader) has none or two Backgrounds”

Or do you mean the Expedition Leader telling you what other people’s Backgrounds are?

Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: he/they

31-05-2017 10:25:01 UTC

against

Cpt_Koen:

31-05-2017 10:47:15 UTC

imperial

Sphinx:

31-05-2017 13:56:28 UTC

against I don’t think it’s necessary, really.

Also it’s an interesting distinction between me having no backgrounds (which I can’t have since only Explorers who are not me have none or two backgrounds) and me not having any value for a Backgrounds variable.

Though it’s weird, since that technically makes the sentence “I have no backgrounds” true as well.

On the other hand, the rules don’t explicitly disallow me having no backgrounds either.

Yet it’s reasonable that I have no backgrounds, but not that I have two backgrounds, even though the rules say the same thing about both.

A non-paradoxical explanation would be if the Backgrounds variable was created including me, and only the restrictions are concerning Explorers who aren’t me.

card:

31-05-2017 16:07:15 UTC

[Sphinx] Interesting wording, I guess that means you could take on backgrounds if you so wished but currently couldn’t “reveal” them to anyone. I’m not certain if you telling someone “I’m a spy” when you aren’t a spy counts as revealing and even if you are a spy the person you’re telling it to can’t verify the truth so it might not be revealing your own background anyway.
  against

pokes:

31-05-2017 23:46:29 UTC

against