Saturday, April 12, 2025

Proposal: Storming Area 51

In “The Break-In” replace “Each Burglar who has the same Location as a Guard is now considered to have Encountered that Guard” with

* For each Location that has both at least one Burglar and and at least one Guard in that location, secretly randomly pair off Burglars and Guards who share that location so that as many pairs as possible are created with no Guard or Burglar being paired off more than once. Then for each pair, the Guard in that pair is considered to have Encountered the Burglar in the pair. If that Burglar has any loot, it is reduced by 1 and the Guard in the pair gains 2 fame.

In the Inattentive Effect replace “If the Agent is a Guard, only Burglars with the Noisy Flaw in the same Location as that Guard are considered to have Encountered that Guard” with

If the Agent is a Guard and would Encounter a Burglar, they only do so if that Burglar is Noisy

One guard shouldn’t be able to simultaneously apprehend 5 burglars. But on the other hand, if you get caught you should drop some loot

Comments

ais523:

13-04-2025 05:42:48 UTC

arrow The existing rules are all based on Burglars encountering Guards. This rule changes it so that Guards encounter Burglars – but the rest of the ruleset still checks to see if Burglars encounter Guards. As such, it (possibly unintentionally) creates a wording scam in which Encounters don’t meaningfully happen at all. (There’s no rule specifying that Encounters are two-way; Agent A encountering Agent B doesn’t necessarily imply that Agent B encounters Agent A.)

DoomedIdeas: he/him

13-04-2025 06:34:58 UTC

arrow

SingularByte: he/him

13-04-2025 09:14:06 UTC

arrow

Kevan: Concierge he/him

13-04-2025 11:08:33 UTC

against

“One guard shouldn’t be able to simultaneously apprehend 5 burglars.” - no “apprehending” is currently happening, though, Burglars can still move around after being encountered.

The Burglars making a clever plan to not be seen at all seems more in keeping with the genre than six Burglars “storming” through the same entrance because if there’s only a single Guard posted there they know that five of them will get through safely.

ais523:

13-04-2025 14:33:32 UTC

CoV imperial – I had noticed the issue Kevan pointed out but thought it probably wouldn’t be that much of an issue (given that they can also be caught on the way back out), but perhaps it is enough of a problem to vote against this.

You must be logged in as a player to post comments.