Thursday, February 20, 2025

Proposal: Tectonic Shift

Withdrawn. Failed by JonathanDark.

Adminned at 21 Feb 2025 15:51:54 UTC

In the rule “Isles of BoardGamia”, replace “2(if the major island is Forbidden Island) or 3” with “2”.

In the same rule, remove all instances of the text “Forbidden Island”.

In the rule “The Networks”, replace “Space 201 on Forbidden Island” with “Space 201 on Hellapagos” and remove the sentence beginning with “Space 300 on Forbidden Island”.

Repeal the rule “Forbidden Island Local Rules”.

In the rule “Meeple Nobility”, remove the text “the Royal of Forbidden Island hates being directly referred to” and remove the text “(or, for the Royal of Forbidden Island, Meeples are encouraged to always refer to them in a very roundabout way)”.

In the same rule, replace every instance of “four” with “three” and replace every instance of “4-player” with “3-player”.

In the rule “Winning”, replace every instance of “400” with “300”.

In the rule “Gates”, replace “and 300, and 399” with “and 299”.

Removing an Island makes the journey to the end a little shorter. No one has come up with a game board idea for the Forbidden Island yet that has stuck, so that’s the reason for choosing that one.

Another option might be making the other island grids smaller, but that requires messing with the grid formula.

Comments

Raven1207: Monarchple he/they

20-02-2025 20:45:21 UTC

Technically Spirit island has no local rules either

JonathanDark: he/him

20-02-2025 22:09:42 UTC

True, but removing that island wouldn’t make getting to the end any faster. Removing a Major Island means the end square is 100 less.

Raven1207: Monarchple he/they

20-02-2025 23:29:02 UTC

imperial

Depending on how other mechanics go, I’m ok-ish with the speed up

JonathanDark: he/him

21-02-2025 00:11:40 UTC

Yeah, I feel like this one might be controversial, if someone actually does have plans for Forbidden Island, or they don’t want to lose the fun “for the Royal of Forbidden Island, Meeples are encouraged to always refer to them in a very roundabout way”.

It’s mostly an experiment on my part to see where people are willing to go to solve the problem of it taking too long to reach the end. If this doesn’t work out, then we need more ways to transport tokens to farther squares.

ais523:

21-02-2025 00:22:08 UTC

imperial

Habanero:

21-02-2025 02:45:34 UTC

against I think 4 islands is enough. I imagine the Kitten Island turquoise squares will speed things up significantly once people get onto other islands. I’ve something in mind for Forbidden Island but am holding back until we get near there

Desertfrog:

21-02-2025 07:54:39 UTC

Apparently the forbidden island is so forbidden that now even its existence has been questioned

JonathanDark: he/him

21-02-2025 15:51:24 UTC

There doesn’t seem to be much enthusiasm for this, so withdrawn.  against