Saturday, August 13, 2011

Proposal: The Crate Escape (amended)

Can’t enact with 6 votes against and 2 for, without a change of vote. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 15 Aug 2011 01:33:56 UTC

If the proposal “The Crate Escape” fails, then this proposal does nothing.

Replace

“If there are fewer than two Crates in the Arena, any Gladiator may - as a daily Action - activate the Crate Dropper by selecting a random Arena Square.”

with:

If there are fewer than two Crates in the Arena, any Gladiator may activate the crate dropper by selecting a random Arena Square. This selection constitutes a Daily Action, regardless of whether a crate has yet been placed in the Arena.

I still think the amendment proposed in “The Crate Escape” is a bit ambiguous. Has the crate dropper been activated if no crate has been dropped?

Comments

Josh: HE/HIM

08-13-2011 20:25:08 UTC

against I don’t think this is needed, and furthermore “constitutes a daily action” could be damaging wording - if this constitutes a daily action, does it affect the allocation of other, unrelated daily actions?

Kevan: HE/HIM

08-13-2011 21:41:46 UTC

I think “constitutes” is fair enough as a synonym for “is”, but all this is doing is changing “X is a daily action, and it causes Y” to “X causes Y, and X is a daily action both before and after Y happens”. X is clearly a daily action anyway.

against

Bucky:

08-13-2011 23:55:19 UTC

against

scshunt:

08-14-2011 07:07:14 UTC

against

Ely:

08-14-2011 16:52:51 UTC

against

Blacky:

08-14-2011 21:20:15 UTC

against

Ienpw III:

08-15-2011 00:04:03 UTC

There’s certainly no *harm* in this. for