Call for Judgment: the Cup is a bloody mess!
Timed out 3 votes to 4. Failed by Kevan.
Adminned at 15 Aug 2011 16:55:08 UTC
There is an issue when a Gladiotor holding the cup dies, as in this case the rules “Blood!” and “Vicory and Glory” contradict each other. The rule “Blood!” states:
Immediately after a Gladiator Dies, if the square where this death occurred is Empty, a Blood Pool is created there.
A contradicting statement is found in the rule “Victory and Glory”:
When the Gladiator holding The ClingBoom Cup Dies, an Instance of CUP is placed on the square where that death occurred, if it is Empty.
Is is not clear which rule takes precedence.
Therefore, in the rule “Victory and Glory” change the sentence:
When the Gladiator holding The ClingBoom Cup Dies, an Instance of CUP is placed on the square where that death occurred, if it is Empty.
to
When the Gladiator holding The ClingBoom Cup Dies, an Instance of CUP is placed on the square where that death occurred, if it is Empty or contains a Blood Pool. If a Blood pool exists in this square, remove it before placing the CUP.
If at least quorum of the EVC on this CfJ contain the string “Agora rulez!” Blacky may declare Victory.
Yeah, a contradiction, have I won now?
scshunt:
Dude, Agora hasn’t had a paradox-victory rule for months.