cause it would let you win

Also, whoever admins this proposal could replace your talk page with “Potato” before passing it. (as your talk page wouldn’t become gamestate upon this proposal passing). This would create a scenario where whoever admins the proposal can decide if you win or not, which not good gameplay.

in favor of the general purpose fix.

It’s a revision of my Talk Page, for exactly that reason. Go ahead and replace it with Potato, then click the link; it will work fine.

Also, your against vote disappoints me; Bucky’s doesn’t, I guess.

It disappoints you that I’d be against someone making an “I win” proposal???

It’s not an “I win” proposal. It’s a “I’m supposed to do this, and then, because I did what I was supposed to, I win” proposal.

Voting against this for that reason just seems… silly.

If your supposed do be able to do something and you can’t, make a proposal that gives you the ability to do that thing, don’t make a proposal that says you did that thing.

in unrelated matters, doesn’t “Archived Rulesets from previous dynasties cannot be modified except by CfJ, and Scribes shall not attempt to modify them. This does not prohibit archiving the current Ruleset at the end of a dynasty.” prevent this proposal from actually doing anything?

wait its not the ruleset nevermind

It’s not an archived Ruleset, it’s a Dynastic History page.

As for your other point, I see no reason why Proposals should be deemed an unacceptable way to do that thing I’m supposed to be able to do.

Does anyone actually have a criticism with the listed Dynastic history?

no. but if its reasonable and part of playing nomic for someone to propose a scam that lets them win, its also reasonable and part of playing nomic for someone to vote against a proposal that lets someone else win.

I’ve enjoyed this dynasty but I’m ready for it to be over and I don’t see me winning so no use to prolong things.

It’s likely going to be over within a week regardless.

(Barring Overtime, that is)

Also worth noting is that I had a writeup for dynasty 88 prepared before RaichuKFM posted this proposal, but opted to take the time to propose a proper fix rather than hack together a ‘my edit counts but yours does not’ proposal.

I liked the concept for this dynasty but I guess we weren’t able to grab enough rules for it to turn out as best it could have. Generally agree with Raichu’s thought about the Dynasty in the other proposal to fix the speaker problem.

note that this doesn’t do much of note anymore. Vote is currently 2-2. Still don’t think this should’ve been done with a proposal, but I’ll switch to FOR if it looks like the proposal is breaking that way to help it pass (or Raichu can SK and get to work on the history for 109 and just use bucky’s generic fix)

Oh shoot. I genuinely did not see that coming, nice play.