Proposal: The Public Realm
Withdrawn. Failed by Kevan.
Adminned at 27 Mar 2024 19:54:03 UTC
Remove all but the first Public Criteria from the list in “Criteria”.
To the top of the list in “Scoring”, add a new bullet point:-
* If it is the responder’s own Snap, then for each Public Criteria that the Shot satisfies, the responder’s Score is increased by 3
In Upgrades, replace “A Snap which meets every Public Criteria” with:-
A Snap which includes a specific named entity that had its own Wikipedia page at Mon 18/03/24—09:00 UTC, in which at least one article of clothing worn by the posting Seeker at the time that the Snap was taken is visible, and which contains a message to the viewer
The concepts of Public and Private Criteria seem a bit disconnected. This makes Public into something that, like Private Criteria, you score - specifically, something you can score for each photo and are rewarded for following when composing it, rather than something you can entirely ignore once you’ve unlocked the everything-in-shot achievement.
This also cuts (for now) the list back down to just “photo taken outside”, as I’m not sure whether the group would want to see the entity/clothing/message aspects in every single photo that gets posted.
but I have learned the blog does not allow comment edits.
this would allow people who already got the first upgrade to get the new upgrade again
NadNavillus: he/him
I could get behind the reorg or the public criteria. However, I like that a shot needs to be something current (daily word) instead of a random photo taken at any time by the seeker.