Tuesday, May 26, 2020

Proposal: The “Table Flip” Endgame [No Victory]

Reached quorum, 6-2. Enacted by Josh
Enacted illegally and re-opened after 10 minutes closed - Josh
Popular and Enacted.—Tantusar

Adminned at 27 May 2020 05:27:27 UTC

Fail all other pending non-Core Proposals, repeal all Dynastic Rules, and declare a Metadynasty with no theme.

Here’s the extreme other end of the spectrum. I don’t know how much traction it’ll pick up. shrugs

Comments

Josh: ELECTOR HE/HIM

26-05-2020 17:18:51 UTC

against metadynasties are a lose state for all players imo

Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: HE/THEY

26-05-2020 17:27:53 UTC

for Given what seems to be a trend of strange dynasties, let’s go for it!

Tantusar: HE/THEY

26-05-2020 17:28:04 UTC

Sometimes a lose state is what is required.

ais523:

26-05-2020 17:31:37 UTC

against

Josh: ELECTOR HE/HIM

26-05-2020 17:43:45 UTC

COV for . It’s been pointed out that this next dynasty is almost certainly the switch dynasty, and that’s a poisoned chalice for anyone who wants player focus on what’s going on. Under the circumstances, a frivolous throwaway might be better.

ais523:

26-05-2020 17:48:58 UTC

Perhaps any metadynasty created by this rule should be explicitly concerned with the Switch, and that should be the theme of the dynasty?

I can easily imagine a dynasty whose purpose is to just act as a prelude to some other dynasty elsewhere, e.g. by defining a few gamestate variables that would likely subsequently be usable in a new dynasty without knowing its theme.

Clucky: HE/HIM

26-05-2020 18:00:40 UTC

against

we’re probably gonna have a metadynasty when we switch to WP anyways. Might mean back to back metadynasties which wouldn’t be much fun.

Kevan: HE/HIM

26-05-2020 18:24:30 UTC

for Seems as good a time as any with a switch two weeks away, and a nice piece of meaningless tradition: the downsides of lacking an Emperor could be patched up dynastically.

[Clucky] Why would we have to start a second metadynasty at the instant of the switch, instead of continuing the first one? The switch is just a moment when we start using a different blog.

derrick: HE/HIM

26-05-2020 18:31:24 UTC

for since folks are killing the die roll proposal.

pokes:

26-05-2020 18:38:29 UTC

for I unidle; quorum’s still 6. I’m not gonna bother updating my row in the Community page.

Clucky: HE/HIM

26-05-2020 18:57:20 UTC

What is the plan for the switch?

I was thinking it would be more “run a trial game alongside normal blognomic, and then assuming it goes well merge the gamestates” like we did before. (note how the second dynasty of josh didn’t actually have a winner. it just ended when we merged blogs)

There is also something to be said about how 75th trombone won’t have the WP blog ready for another three weeks. So while a planned dynasty that has a built in timer and is only designed to last a month would work well, a non-planned meta dynasty would leave us in this weird state where we need to make sure the dynasty doesn’t end to soon.

Darknight: HE/HIM

26-05-2020 21:01:02 UTC

for better then nothing lol

Trigon:

26-05-2020 21:36:27 UTC

for Let’s do it!

ayesdeeef:

26-05-2020 22:15:34 UTC

for

Clucky: HE/HIM

27-05-2020 01:33:11 UTC

for CoV just incase somehow it helps this pass sooner