Saturday, February 21, 2015

Proposal: This dynasty could be ruined by outside interference; let’s prevent that happening in future

Was vetoed by kevan while his dynasty was still in progress.  Darknight

Adminned at 22 Feb 2015 21:56:38 UTC

To the end of the bulletted list in the Core rule “Fair Play”, add the following bullet point:

  • A Crewmember should not try to gain an advantage via persuading an Idle Crewmember to unidle, or a non-Crewmember to register for the game.

Also means that if Agora ever invades again, it’ll actually be against the rules.

Comments

Josh: he/they

21-02-2015 00:37:13 UTC

for

Sylphrena:

21-02-2015 01:44:56 UTC

for

_Fox_:

21-02-2015 06:25:45 UTC

for

Bucky:

21-02-2015 17:37:39 UTC

against

Kevan: City he/him

21-02-2015 20:53:08 UTC

“Also means that if Agora ever invades again, it’ll actually be against the rules.”

No, it would make it against the rules for BlogNomic players to stop them. An Agoran who had never played BlogNomic could coordinate a group to sign up and force a CfJ through, and the existing BlogNomic players would be unable to ask friends or older players to help out in response (which is exactly what we had to do last time).

And surely Ais523 realises all of this. If Agora want to have a friendly game of Nomic invasion where they define the flag and we try to stop them from capturing it, please just ask us.

veto

ais523:

21-02-2015 21:45:12 UTC

I didn’t realise that, and this was not any sort of scam attempt.

(Agora is basically inactive right now, although there’s talk of resurrecting it.)

ais523:

21-02-2015 21:52:07 UTC

(Or to put it another way, if any Nomic invasion’s going to be going on in the near future, it’d almost certainly be BlogNomic instigating it.)

RaichuKFM: she/her

21-02-2015 22:40:26 UTC

against Pointless vote to announce that I’ve unidled and that quorum is still 6.