Monday, July 18, 2011

Proposal: This shouldn’t be an issue but…

At 1-7, cannot be enacted without CoV. Failed. -coppro

Adminned at 18 Jul 2011 22:11:12 UTC

In the Rule ‘Death and Scorekeeping’, change the text

A Gladiator can never receive a Frag for their own Death, or more than one Frag for the same Death.

to

A Gladiator can never gain a Frag for their own Death, or more than one Frag for the same Death, even if this rule or another rule would cause them to gain one.  Rules should not allow Gladiators to gain Frags except in conjunction with a Death.

Some people in IRC were arguing that rules causing frags to be gained would override the “can’t receive Frags” somehow.  I do not agree with their reasoning, but am proposing to ‘patch’ it anyway.

Comments

scshunt:

18-07-2011 02:35:38 UTC

against this is a no-op.

mideg:

18-07-2011 07:06:01 UTC

against I don’t see how a Gladiator could receive more then one frag for the same Death. If someone would care to explain to me the loophole this supposedly closes, I might change my mind. :-)

Prince Anduril:

18-07-2011 11:48:15 UTC

against

Kevan: HE/HIM

18-07-2011 12:03:52 UTC

against That some anonymous IRC chat “somehow” says we need this isn’t very compelling. Isn’t it covered by the Prioritisation section of the Appendix?

Blacky:

18-07-2011 17:14:09 UTC

against

SingularByte:

18-07-2011 20:34:56 UTC

against

mideg:

18-07-2011 21:10:24 UTC

I start to wonder who “some people” are, because it seems that no one agrees with them….

Josh: RICHARDO VON NESTOR HE/HIM

18-07-2011 21:11:03 UTC

against