Monday, January 04, 2010

Call for Judgment: This sucks.

Failed, 13 votes to 3 (as best as I can make out). Josh

Adminned at 05 Jan 2010 06:35:36 UTC

Reset the poles to their default locations. Reset the coordinate system. Move all players whose EVC on this proposal contains the phrase “South Pole Sucks” to O’Hare International Airport.

Comments

Klisz:

04-01-2010 16:30:45 UTC

for  Though the rider does nothing as this is not a proposal.

spikebrennan:

04-01-2010 16:40:03 UTC

for South Pole Sucks

redtara: they/them

04-01-2010 16:43:54 UTC

for South Pole Sucks.
It is a proposal in the standard English usage of the word, right? I am proposing we fix this mess.

ais523:

04-01-2010 16:55:22 UTC

against The only plausible reason to make this a CFJ not a proposal is to dodge veto and deferential mechanics. So against due to the abuse of process.

Klisz:

04-01-2010 16:57:13 UTC

CoV against  per ais.

Bucky:

04-01-2010 16:57:56 UTC

against

redtara: they/them

04-01-2010 17:00:13 UTC

No, it’s actually so this doesn’t have to wait for the queue, so that we can start with our new mechanics ASAP.

Don’t be so suspicious.

Josh: Observer he/they

04-01-2010 17:17:47 UTC

for South Pole Sucks. Although the North Pole is quite nice.

Kevan: he/him

04-01-2010 17:55:02 UTC

against

alethiophile:

04-01-2010 19:02:25 UTC

against Use a Wish to undo it if you don’t like it.

redtara: they/them

04-01-2010 19:19:07 UTC

I can’t; the djinni’s in the lamp, and this is multi-part.

90000:

04-01-2010 19:40:52 UTC

for what’s the difference between props and cfj’s in terms of what they can do to gamestate & rules?

NoOneImportant:

04-01-2010 19:51:07 UTC

imperial

Klisz:

04-01-2010 19:54:06 UTC

@lars: It says: Move all players whose EVC on this proposal contains the phrase “South Pole Sucks” to O’Hare International Airport. (emphasis added)

Darknight: he/him

04-01-2010 20:41:26 UTC

against

Nausved:

04-01-2010 21:21:15 UTC

against

I am bothered by the use of a Call for Judgment to undo a wish. In my opinion, this is not a question of interpretation and it is hardly urgent, especially since everyone in the South Pole now has an escape route through New Zealand.

But just in case: South Pole Sucks.

Qwazukee:

04-01-2010 21:39:36 UTC

for South Pole Sucks

Aquafraternally Yours:

04-01-2010 22:20:24 UTC

against

redtara: they/them

04-01-2010 23:09:41 UTC

NOI: Can’t vote imperial on a CFJ.
CoV against South Pole Sucks due to Pangaea.

Aquafraternally Yours:

04-01-2010 23:25:32 UTC

Actually, I figured the Pangaea thing would help people escape.  Is that not the case?

redtara: they/them

05-01-2010 00:36:44 UTC

Yes, hence my CoV.

Aquafraternally Yours:

05-01-2010 00:41:56 UTC

*slaps forehead* Totally read your post wrong, Ienpw.  My bad.

arthexis: he/him

05-01-2010 06:14:48 UTC

against Spurious.

Qwazukee:

05-01-2010 06:20:57 UTC

That’s not what that word means, arth.

There:

05-01-2010 07:29:54 UTC

against This feels like an abuse of the system. South Pole Sucks though.

NoOneImportant:

05-01-2010 07:39:38 UTC

imperial
CoV to include “South Pole Sucks”

NoOneImportant:

05-01-2010 07:40:16 UTC

against
CoV to valid vote, also “South Pole Sucks”

Oze:

05-01-2010 09:52:50 UTC

against South Pole Sucks