Wednesday, September 24, 2014

Proposal: Throw-ins Reset Assists

Timed out 3 votes to 4. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 26 Sep 2014 00:51:39 UTC

In the Rule “The Throw-in”, change the text

any Player may transfer the Ball to their own possession.

to

any Player may put the ball Out of Play.

If a majority of EVCs on this contain the word “rename”, move the contents of the rule “The Throw-in” to the rule “The Penalty Kick”

 

Comments

ayesdeeef:

24-09-2014 01:40:38 UTC

Isn’t this effectively the same thing with an extra step? against

Sylphrena:

24-09-2014 02:14:50 UTC

for It isn’t because in this case assisting players lose their status if the person with the ball is slow.

Sylphrena:

24-09-2014 02:16:16 UTC

Oh uh changing my vote to “rename”  for (assuming I can do that)

nomic^3:

24-09-2014 04:48:02 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

24-09-2014 07:48:21 UTC

against Randomly miskicking the ball to a sleeping player does enough damage already.

ayesdeeef:

24-09-2014 16:57:53 UTC

Keeping my vote as against per Kevan. It’s so hard to do anything in the current system.

ayesdeeef:

24-09-2014 16:58:52 UTC

What I meant is, if this passes, scoring will become even less viable, and that is bad because it is already hard in the current system.

ayesdeeef:

24-09-2014 17:01:57 UTC

Sylphrena, you are right because you put another For vote in your second vote, making it your EVC, which is what the Proposal is checking for.

Person93:

25-09-2014 15:54:15 UTC

against

RaichuKFM: she/her

26-09-2014 00:36:53 UTC

against