Wednesday, November 28, 2007

Proposal: Tinkering with Devices

time out fail 2-7. failed by aaronwinborn

Adminned at 29 Nov 2007 20:34:45 UTC

In the rule called “Devices” replace this text:

“The Valkyrie then rolls DICE12 in the GNDT a number of times equal to that Tinkerer’s Tinkering statistic.”

with this text:

“The Valkyrie then rolls DICEX, where X is 13 minus the Tinkerer’s Tinkering statistic, in the GNDT a number of times equal to that Tinkerer’s Tinkering statistic.”

and replace the reference to “DICE12” in the example with “DICE8”.

In essence, this makes it increasingly easier for Einherjar with a higher Tinkering statistic to create a device.

Comments

Amnistar: he/him

28-11-2007 03:45:44 UTC

against It’s already easier for someone with more tinkering to succeed.  If you do this you gurantee (almost) that a person with Tinkering over…5 is gonna get at least 1 point devices.

Hix:

28-11-2007 04:13:04 UTC

Quite a drastic change….  It could make things more interesting, but I’m not sure it’s fair.

Josh: Observer he/they

28-11-2007 06:39:40 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

28-11-2007 12:48:52 UTC

against

aaronwinborn:

28-11-2007 14:20:22 UTC

imperial

Clucky: he/him

28-11-2007 14:33:16 UTC

against

So if your tinkering is ten, you would on average get 3-4 points out of your roll. Seems a little too powerful to me.

Chivalrybean:

28-11-2007 15:15:22 UTC

imperial

Shadowclaw:

29-11-2007 12:03:12 UTC

against

Hix:

29-11-2007 18:51:53 UTC

against (2-6)