Saturday, July 20, 2019

Call for Judgment: To continue a war… [Appendix]

Timed out / fewer than a quorum not voting against. Failed 1-4 by Kevan.

Adminned at 22 Jul 2019 08:00:00 UTC

Make this post an official post, and render all edits to it as of 0100 UTC on Saturday July 20, 2019 to be legal. Make any and all posts and actions that would not have been illegal if said post was an official post to be legal.

If a number of EVC’s contain the phrase “Fix, maybe?” do the following:

In the Appendix, under “Gamestate Tracking,” amend the following:

A non-official post may not, through editing of the blog or otherwise, be changed into an official post, with the following two exceptions:

To read as:

A non-official post may not, through editing of the blog or otherwise, be changed into an official post, with the following three exceptions:

To that same paragraph, append:

Thirdly, if a post that is not an official post is less than an hour old, and has no comments on it that would constitute as being part of a legal action according to the Ruleset if it were official (such as comments with voting icons for votable matters), then the author may change the category and/or add, edit, or subtract up to ten characters in the post.

Making the Fourth campaign official, as well as adding a possible fix, though I personally dislike the fix.

Comments

TyGuy6:

07-20-2019 06:09:47 UTC

Making the campaign official is illegal, even by CfJ. (And for good reason, the rule is to avoid further confusion.) Appendix trumps all other rules.

The rest of this is ok, though it should have been a separate Proposal, IMO. And I don’t believe that the “if it were official” phrasing works in most cases. It’s a hypothetical situation where the post is an official ... what? Official means follows a format, and if it doesn’t it can’t result in legal action comments anyway. Good premise, just needs a very small rewording. against

Kevan:

07-20-2019 09:11:28 UTC

against The fix is clunky (why not combine the new clause with the first?) and given that the Campaign didn’t get very far we might as well just roll up a new one.

derrick:

07-20-2019 12:18:11 UTC

against

Ienpw III:

07-21-2019 16:22:02 UTC

against