Tuesday, December 05, 2006

Proposal: Tome Circulation

Timed out. Failed 2-3. Admined by Clucky.

Adminned at 07 Dec 2006 12:03:10 UTC

Thought I’d repropose this legally.

Add the following to the Ruleset, immediately before section 2.7.1:

A Student may give away eir copy of a Tome, if e can find another Student willing to receive it.  After this happens, the first Student no longer possesses the copy and the second Student possesses it (obviously).

Comments

Clucky: he/him

05-12-2006 21:29:39 UTC

against  This can be too easily abused.

1) Lost students can give all their tomes to another student of their choice to prevent them from being flinched.
2) If my proposal passes, this allows students with many tomes to work their way around giving up tomes.
3) With the Tome of the Week, a student could get on, give all copies of the tome away eimself before anyone else had a chance.

Bucky: Proprietor

06-12-2006 01:04:40 UTC

for .  If you trust anyone enough to have them hold your tomes for you, you deserve to lose them.

Clucky: he/him

06-12-2006 01:54:39 UTC

That isn’t my point. My point is that trusting people could abuse this rule. Unless you think Scheming is good…

Combustable:

06-12-2006 02:18:18 UTC

against

Tommy:

06-12-2006 12:08:02 UTC

Scheming is good.  I am a little worried by your third point, though.  I wonder if we could persuade Bucky to change the wording of his rule slightly.

Bucky: Proprietor

07-12-2006 02:28:12 UTC

Noted

ChronosPhaenon:

07-12-2006 15:59:46 UTC

against