Thursday, November 15, 2007

Proposal: Town Meeting:  Second Opinion

Invalid XOR Vetoed
—Hix

Adminned at 16 Nov 2007 19:11:07 UTC

I’m not totally convinced by the late Tiberias’s argument, but his line about Acuity Points is pretty clear.  Hix and BobTHJ decided to kill him and take the resulting points for themselves, rather than setting up a Town Meeting to lynch him, despite the fact that he’d already exhausted his poison supply and was jailed.

We need an Alchemist who can verify Hix’s evidence, and we need to redistribute the guns to people who aren’t now an AP ahead of the rest of us.

Set Hix’s Occupation to Cardinal and BobTHJ’s Occupation to Archbishop.  Remove the Guns and Silver Bullets from Hix’s and BobTHJ’s Inventory and put them in the late Mayor’s.

Set the Occupation of the living Villager mentioned in the comments by living Villagers on this post the most times (in the form “(Name) for Alchemist”) to Alchemist.  The total should count only the latest comment of this form from each living Villager.  Ignore mentions of Villagers who have commented with the phrase “I despise alchemy.”  In the case of a tie, do not make anyone the Alchemist.

Give a Gun and a Silver Bullet to each of the two living Villagers mentioned in the comments by living Villagers on this post the most times (in the form “(Name) for Sheriff”).  The total should count only the latest comment of this form from each living Villager.  Ignore mentions of Villagers who have commented with the phrase “I hate guns.”  In the case of a three-or-more-way tie, leave the Guns in the Mayor’s Inventory.

Comments

Brendan: he/him

15-11-2007 13:43:20 UTC

Oracular rufio for Alchemist, ShadowClaw for Sheriff.

BobTHJ:

15-11-2007 15:22:26 UTC

against I would vote Imperial on this except I don’t think it would have any meaning. I’m not opposed to being put under scrutiny for my actions, but I would prefer to keep my items.

Although I was forced to resign my position as a man of the cloth, I am still here to serve the village and put an end to this tyranny.

Brendan: he/him

15-11-2007 15:27:20 UTC

“Forced?” You gave it up willingly so you could shoot a prisoner before he made it to trial.

BobTHJ:

15-11-2007 16:00:43 UTC

Forced via moral obligation to end the life of a known werewolf before they could escape and cause further harm.

In any case:
Brendan for Alchemist
BobTHJ for Sheriff

Bucky:

15-11-2007 21:47:52 UTC

I hate guns.

Oracular rufio:

15-11-2007 21:49:29 UTC

Hix said multiple times that he did it to prevent Tiberius from poisoning the well once he figured out he was going to be killed.  I believe that all of the attempted murder also happened before Tiberius got rid of his poison (by poisoning the well) and due to a loophole was still able to do so from prison.  Note that Hix made a proposal to fix this, but it didn’t go through in time.

That said:
for
Oracular rufio for Alchemist
Brendan for Sheriff

(If we make Brendan the Alchemist, we lose our Solicitor.)

Oracular rufio:

15-11-2007 22:04:18 UTC

Looking at the timestamps, Tiberius emptied his inventory and made his post at 2300, and Hix made his posts about shooting Tiberius and fixing the loophole at 1700 and 1900 - before the poison was gone.

Oracular rufio:

15-11-2007 22:06:50 UTC

Actually, they were both at 1700.  I just can’t read. :P

Hix:

15-11-2007 23:42:39 UTC

This town meeting was called at night.  veto

Rodlen:

15-11-2007 23:44:16 UTC

for

Hix:

15-11-2007 23:57:26 UTC

Seems odd to force someone to become Cardinal.

Why not allow an “I despise Organized Religion” rider as you do for Alchemy and Guns?

against

Oracular rufio:

16-11-2007 06:39:02 UTC

Hix: it was called at night, so it’s not a town meeting.  It’s a proposal whose title begins with “Town Meeting:”.

Kevan: he/him

16-11-2007 10:55:07 UTC

veto Illegal town meeting.