Tuesday, January 21, 2025

Proposal: Triumphs unclaimed

Forcibly failed by Triumphs unclaimed, CFJ edition -SingularByte

Adminned at 22 Jan 2025 12:06:06 UTC

In the rule Teams and Targets {I}, remove the third bullet point and its contents.

As of right now, claims are orphaned. This renders triumphs unearnable as per 4.2.3 “A Participant may not take any dynastic actions that are contingent on the specific value of an Orphan Variable. “

Comments

ais523:

21-01-2025 21:08:31 UTC

This definitely needs doing, although I’m not sure whether or not it breaks things – Claims aren’t an orphaned variable, they aren’t a variable at all. I guess that makes it hard to determine what the value is, though.

This should probably be a CFJ rather than a proposal, though? I think it counts as “something that needs urgent attention”.

SingularByte: he/him

21-01-2025 21:13:08 UTC

It is an orphaned variable. Mutable Gamestate specifically takes ownership of variables that cease to have a definition, so as of now, it’s owned by that rule’s third bullet point but not tracked by its fourth.

ais523:

21-01-2025 21:18:48 UTC

OK – I’ve made a CFJ that’s effectively identical to this proposal, as I think this is the sort of fix that benefits from being able to jump the queue.

Josh: he/they

22-01-2025 10:50:56 UTC

against For the CfJ.