Monday, October 24, 2011

Proposal: Ungenericizing generic references

Self-Killed—arthexis

Adminned at 25 Oct 2011 20:09:41 UTC

If the proposal entitled “Allow generic references” passed, append the following to rule 3.1, “Keywords”: A generic keyword in the Core or Dynastic rules can be replaced with its thematic synonym (defined below) by any admin.

Comments

zuff: Idle

24-10-2011 03:41:09 UTC

for

Murphy: Idle

24-10-2011 03:58:57 UTC

for

arthexis: he/himIdle

24-10-2011 04:12:30 UTC

for

Bucky: Idle

24-10-2011 04:12:49 UTC

for

omd: Idle

24-10-2011 04:40:53 UTC

against These proposals won’t help if you want to replace existing rule text that contains the ungeneric words—you’d still have to state it explicitly.  What about just interpreting proposals as if they contained the appropriate thematic words in place of the generic ones?

Klisz: Idle

24-10-2011 05:09:28 UTC

for

Qwazukee: Idle

24-10-2011 05:49:33 UTC

against

zuff: Idle

24-10-2011 06:07:31 UTC

comex: Yeah, but if the other proposal passes, it’ll be way worse without this than with. So it’s best to vote FOR this just in case it does.

scshunt: Idle

24-10-2011 06:41:25 UTC

for

Prince Anduril: Idle

24-10-2011 07:29:05 UTC

for

Kevan: Concierge he/him

24-10-2011 08:28:06 UTC

against “Append” means “add to the end”, so nothing is “defined below”.

ChronosPhaenon: Idle

24-10-2011 12:56:47 UTC

against

southpointingchariot: Idle

24-10-2011 13:12:51 UTC

imperial

Prince Anduril: Idle

24-10-2011 13:15:05 UTC

against CoV per Kevan.

Wooble: Idle

24-10-2011 13:42:47 UTC

imperial

scshunt: Idle

24-10-2011 14:33:34 UTC

against

Ely: Idle

24-10-2011 14:50:28 UTC

against

Clucky: he/him

24-10-2011 17:32:59 UTC

People who know BN’s history better than I do—we used to be able to do something like this. For a while AAs also changed the idle keyword (to stuff like Rotten for the vegetable dynasty). Anyone know when it was changed to only let you edit Emperor/Player?

Clucky: he/him

24-10-2011 17:48:29 UTC

Clucky: he/him

24-10-2011 18:01:36 UTC

also against

Ornithopter: Idle

24-10-2011 18:20:44 UTC

against

Pavitra: Idle

24-10-2011 18:55:36 UTC

for Remember this is conditional; only vote AGAINST if you’d rather have the other one and not this than have both. Your opinion on whether the other one should pass is irrelevant to how you should vote here.

Spitemaster: Idle

24-10-2011 19:15:38 UTC

imperial

southpointingchariot: Idle

24-10-2011 19:27:46 UTC

cov for

Klisz: Idle

24-10-2011 20:20:33 UTC

against CoV per Kevan.

redtara: they/themIdle

24-10-2011 20:23:23 UTC

Self-kill per Kevan. That’s what I get for writing proposals at that hour.  against

Wakukee: Idle

24-10-2011 23:59:09 UTC

against