BlogNomic: The First Dynasty of Desertfrog

“ then those Spells are cast in the same order as those Wizards’ order in the Wizard Ring, lowest to highest. ”

No other wizard had cast the greed spell when I was processing lendun’s casting off the spell. So why shouldn’t he get the full five stars? It’s clearly not what was intended, but letter of the rules trumps spirit if the rules

I agree with Clucky on this one. No matter the intent of the rules, the wording uses the verb “cast” in multiple places, giving it definition as to what it means for this dynasty. “cast” as it relates to spells has no definition of when it applies until that bullet:

* Each Wizard’s Spell is cast…

indicating when a cast actually happens.

If another Battle Master had interpreted it a different way, and lendunistus had put up a CfJ, I would vote in his favor to receive 5 Stars in this scenario, because I think Clucky’s interpretation is the correct one.

That’s fair! I think this is just on the border between “clearly this interpretation” and “it could be either”, I didn’t expect everyone to agree with me.

I was looking over it again just now and it seems you’re right - “selecting” a spell to cast isn’t treated the same as actually casting it, which is how I interpreted it initially. Withdrawn

...you can’t withdraw CfJs, can you

No you cant. We’ll just have to vote it down.

and there we go