Wednesday, March 27, 2024

Story Post: Upgrade Request for Snap 17

Cannot be enacted with 4 against. Josh

Adminned at 28 Mar 2024 17:43:52 UTC

Snap 17 is taken in the same place (32 seconds in) in the song “So You Can Sleep Enter” by “Ned Navillus” as Snap 16 which was made by another seeker.

Therefore I think I have satisfied the clause “A Snap that was taken in the same place as another Snap taken by a different Seeker.” and so fulfill that Upgrade Benchmark


Josh: Observer he/they

27-03-2024 19:52:50 UTC

Sadly you are playing it in Spotify whereas I was playing it in Tidal.  against

Clucky: he/him

27-03-2024 20:10:45 UTC

It’s still the same place in the track/album though

Josh: Observer he/they

27-03-2024 20:21:33 UTC

So we have at least three possible defintions of “place” - location in the track, programme in which it is being played, and physical location in space - and it fails to meet two of the three.

JonathanDark: he/him

27-03-2024 20:26:50 UTC

against For the specific reason claimed (there may be other reasons that could be a valid upgrade request)

Clucky: he/him

27-03-2024 20:33:24 UTC

It only needs to meet one definition though…

NadNavillus: he/him

28-03-2024 12:07:56 UTC

Vibes of bad Supreme Court decisions, but I think I have to play the originalist… what’s was the intention and understanding of the word “place”? I think that might have been pointing to a physical location.


Kevan: he/him

28-03-2024 16:19:08 UTC

against I don’t think a photograph can be taken “in” a place in a song.