Thursday, March 06, 2008

Proposal: Upside-Down

already has 2 pending proposals—Yoda

Adminned at 06 Mar 2008 14:01:28 UTC

Add sub-rule to the rule “Sailing”:

Upside-Down [1st and 7th]: If any other rule is based on order of all Ranks and applies (in specific moment) only to Captains (two or more) of 1st and 7th Ranks (e.g. in battle between them), for that moment and for needs of that other rule these Ranks will be swapped (1st acts as 7th and 7th acts as 1st). If that other rule is based on only one of affected Captains’ Rank, no Ranks will be swapped. This rule of Rank-swapping applies only to situations of rivalry (e.g. selecting a winner or determining profits each Captain would gained) and not cooperation (e.g. sum of Ranks to achieve a goal).

This rule does not affect any existing rule, it’s for future.
I don’t know how to put it as simple as the idea is itself.

posted by Jacek_FH at 06 Mar 2008 14:50:00 UTC Comments (5)

Comments

Oze:

06-03-2008 16:34:11 UTC

against Not sure what this means.

Yoda:

06-03-2008 17:38:54 UTC

If I am reading this correctly, Rank-swapping will only occur when two or more Captains of Ranks 1st or 7th only are participating in some event where they are against each other.  Is this right?

arthexis: he/him

06-03-2008 18:07:02 UTC

I could see the uses, but I’m not sure…
imperial

Jacek_FH:

06-03-2008 18:47:39 UTC

“If I am reading this correctly, Rank-swapping will only occur when two or more Captains of Ranks 1st or 7th only are participating in some event where they are against each other.  Is this right? “

Mostly, but it could be for example rule of dividing loot amoungs allied Captains.

Darknight: he/him

06-03-2008 21:39:00 UTC

against too confusing in its current wording arrr