Best Scene: Darth Cliche
For falling rocks and dead everyones.

Worst Scene: Josh
Because I don’t like the name Josh.

Best Scene: Postscript
Worst Scene: Underdeep
Best Music Arrangement: Hallelucination!
Best Original Punchline: Hallelucination!
Worst Original Punchline: The Stars Below

Best scene:Rocks fall, everyone dies
Worst scene: Hallelucination!

There is no such scene as “Josh”.

You didn’t have to tell him ^_^

Oh, or “Darth Cliche”, but I suppose it doesn’t matter so long as the consensus it that you’re uniquely identifying a scene.

Best Scene: Underdeep
Worst Scene: A Pitt
Best Supporting Actor: Underdeep

And to partly balance Darth’s legal-but-inappropriate votes with my own:-

Best Original Punchline: The Stars Below
Worst Original Punchline: Hallelucination!

By the time voting has finished on this act, the fix proposal will probably have passed, which will beg the question of whether nominations have to be valid at the time of posting, the time of counting, or both.

I interpret the rules as being you won’t be able to cast votes on those categories once the proposal passes. But if the vote is already cast, it’s legal.

That seems logical, given precedent on retroactivity, but I think it’s still worth a CfJ.

Is that how you want to do it? So be it.

Best Scene: Rocks Fall, Everyone Dies
Worst Scene: The Stars Below
Worst Original Punchline: The Stars Below

Not really, or I would have done the first time around.

Best scene:Rocks fall, everyone dies
Worst scene: Hallelucination!
Worst original punchline: Hallelucination!

Change of vote.

Best Scene: Rocks Fall, Everyone Dies
Worst Scene: Underdeep
Worst Original Punchline: The Stars Below

Best Scene: The Note
Best Supporting Actor: Angelina Jolie (The Note)
Worst Scene: The Stars Below

Best Scene: Rocks Fall, Everyone Dies (awesome title)
Worst Scene: Hallelucination!
Best Supporting Actor / Actress: The Note (Angelina Jolie)

Note: The first thing I came up with for my heavily-voted-for scene was the title. The script of it was originally going to kill off the hero.

Thanks Influenza for continuing to do my counting. A completely corrupt metagame advantage has already been promised to him as compensation.

Best Scene: Darth Cliche (Rocks fall etc.) +1
Worst Scene: Gnauga (Hallelucination) -1
Best Supporting Actor: Kevan (The Note, Angelina Jolie) +0.5
Best Music Arrangement: Gnauga +0.5
Best Original Punchline: Josh +0.5, Gnauga +0.5
Worst Original Punchline: Josh -0.5, Gnauga -0.5

Summary: DC +1, Gnauga -0.5, Kevan +0.5. Impressive vote-countering, folks.