Wednesday, May 02, 2018

Proposal: voting required

Reached Quorum 7 to 0. Enacted by Derrick

Adminned at 02 May 2018 12:45:56 UTC

Change “At Closing Time, the Candidate who has received the most valid ballots has achieved victory. If there is a tie for the most valid ballots, and if this resolution has not already been done, any Pawn may note which Candidates are tied and resolve the tie randomly with the GNDT.” to

At Closing Time, the Candidate who has received the most valid ballots and has cast a valid ballot has achieved victory. If there is a tie for the most valid ballots and those Candidates have cast a valid ballot, and if this resolution has not already been done, any Pawn may note which Candidates are tied and resolve the tie between the noted Candidates randomly with the GNDT.

Comments

Kevan: he/him

02-05-2018 07:50:46 UTC

for

Doesn’t cover cases where two players each received 2 Ballots, but only one of them cast a Ballot. But we can announce victory by proposal if something like that happens.

Madrid:

02-05-2018 08:48:36 UTC

for

card:

02-05-2018 09:10:21 UTC

[Kevan] I thought that “If there is a tie for the most valid ballots and those Candidates have cast a valid ballot,” would have covered that case.

Kevan: he/him

02-05-2018 09:22:01 UTC

There’d be a tie for most valid ballots received, but those Candidates would not have both cast a valid ballot, so the “and” condition would fail.

pokes:

02-05-2018 10:53:39 UTC

for

Corona:

02-05-2018 10:59:00 UTC

for

Thunder: he/him

02-05-2018 12:13:51 UTC

for

derrick: he/him

02-05-2018 12:40:33 UTC

for

I have unidled myself. Quorum is 6, as there are now 10 pawns.