Sunday, November 10, 2019

Proposal: Waning Boon

Fewer than a quorum not voting against. Failed 2 votes to 3 by Kevan.

Adminned at 12 Nov 2019 09:26:31 UTC

Enact a new rule, “A Pause for Reflection”:-

If the Adventurer named Kevan is not a Monster, any Adventurer may perform the following atomic action:-

* Replace “An Adventurer can have more than 1 of the same Boon.” with “An Adventurer can have up to 3 of the same Boon.” in the ruleset.
* For each Adventurer with more than 3 of the same Boon, remove all of their Boons.
* Repeal this rule.

Maxing out individual Boons feels a bit bland, now that it’s happened twice. Delaying it until the next round to show that I’m not trying to change anything about the current fight.


The Duke of Waltham: he/him

10-11-2019 21:06:37 UTC

Ah… I’m afraid you’re right.  for


10-11-2019 21:12:05 UTC



10-11-2019 21:44:35 UTC



11-11-2019 00:26:54 UTC

Not really. These boons were designed, I assume, to be collected as specialties. Many of them say, X, where X is how many of this boon you have. If you want to make it a diverse collection, and not a debuff plus boon reset, you should increase the number of boons allowed, then make the limit 5 of one kind.

I suspect there’s more involved, in any case.


11-11-2019 00:41:33 UTC

against this rule repeals itself after one use


11-11-2019 00:43:45 UTC

Oh wait imperial


11-11-2019 04:28:39 UTC

Doomed. DOOMED, I SAY!!!


11-11-2019 04:31:50 UTC

+2 pts to Kevan. Well played, good sir Monster.

Kevan: he/him

11-11-2019 09:00:43 UTC

Specialisation is still there, I just thought it seemed a bit boring if we all ended up having one big boon each. We might as well make it “every player has 1 Boon” and factor out all the X calculations.

Making it a self-repealing rule after the end of the current battle is just an alternative to proposing that everyone loses their 5xBoons right now, which I’d have expected the current combatants to object to. Not sure what the doom and +2 is about here.

The Duke of Waltham: he/him

11-11-2019 15:33:24 UTC

I still think this ought to pass, but if it does I’ll strongly support an increase in the power of each individual Boon.


12-11-2019 00:42:16 UTC

upon reflection, i’d rather have 1 boon each with more power behind them.  against