Thursday, September 17, 2009

Proposal: Watching Fix

Self-Vetoed -Darth

Adminned at 17 Sep 2009 15:58:37 UTC

Change the text of Rule 2.3.1. “I’m Being Watched” to:

A Survivor cannot take an action that would change the Status of another Survivor if the prior is being Watched by the latter.

Patching arth’s loophole.

Comments

ais523:

09-17-2009 15:13:03 UTC

against This doesn’t patch the problem correctly, because randomness is involved. I’d prefer something along the lines of “If a Survivor would end up having to change the Status of a Survivor that is watching him, the action succeeds as normal except that that Status is not changed”.

Qwazukee:

09-17-2009 15:19:20 UTC

imperial

arthexis:

09-17-2009 15:28:41 UTC

against per ais

arthexis:

09-17-2009 20:00:59 UTC

Thought I think even ais’ wording is incorrect, unless you actually want us tu damage the living, just not infecting them.

arthexis:

09-17-2009 20:02:32 UTC

One final thing: In fact I don’t like at all how watching works. My original idea (back at the start of the dynasty) was going be quite different. Instead of watching the Infected, you could watch a friendly survivor to make sure others didn’t attack him/her, so it would be more like teamwork than self-defence.

dogfish:

09-17-2009 20:57:27 UTC

imperial I think a teamwork approach would be better too.

Klisz:

09-17-2009 22:58:11 UTC

veto  s/v. Also, Qwaz and dogfish have voted VETO.