Thursday, September 08, 2011

Proposal: We are not worthy.

Timed out 5 votes to 4. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 11 Sep 2011 05:05:34 UTC

Change the subrule “Victorious Return” under “Sighting” to read:

The lifeboat can be Ashore. Initially, the lifeboat is not Ashore.
If the lifeboat is Ashore, and a single Survivor (the “Spokesperson”) has a higher Score than each other Survivor, then the Spokesperson may declare Victory.
A Survivor’s Score is the sum of their Sanity and the number of Valuable Items they own.

Add a new point bullet to the list in subrule “Flags” to rule “Personal Belongings”:

$ Valuable

Add to Subrule “Salvaging!” under Rule “Personal belongings”:

When salvaging an Item, the Survivor who is salvaging it may add a Valuable flag to it if they think that is a particulary valuable Item in an economic point of view, and remembering the historical context. Before removing the uncertain Flag or the Item as per rule “Personal Belongings”, the Captain may remove the Valuable Flag and make the Item’s owner lose 1 Sanity.

Add a Valuable Flag to a Victorian Ring~ and Leather cased desk clock made by Curtis of Horspool~.

Getting home Sane is nice, but getting home with some money to spend is even better! This would make some really unuseful Items worth keeping.


Kevan: HE/HIM

09-08-2011 10:33:44 UTC

for Although I don’t like this being a “guess whether the Captain will agree that it is valuable” game. Maybe we should drag the Floating Rubbish list onto a wiki page and propose to flag a load of them as Valuable.

Prince Anduril:

09-08-2011 12:13:04 UTC



09-08-2011 13:04:42 UTC



09-08-2011 14:56:21 UTC

against I don’t like this at all, because getting hold of items is currently far easier for players who log on a log and constantly scour the GNDT for theft options. That (in my view) isn’t what Nomic should be about.


09-08-2011 14:57:02 UTC

On a log? What is this, Dr Seuss? Should have been “log on a lot”!


09-08-2011 17:50:12 UTC



09-09-2011 03:32:40 UTC


Darknight: HE/HIM

09-09-2011 03:48:32 UTC



09-09-2011 15:33:34 UTC