Monday, October 12, 2020

Call for Judgment: What’s a Gaia!?!? What’s an Island?!?!!

Quorum reached. Passes 7-0—Enacted by Clucky

Adminned at 12 Oct 2020 16:48:11 UTC

If the CfJ here: https://blognomic.com/archive/everlasting_weather has been enacted, this CfJ does nothing. Otherwise, if it is still pending, fail it.

In the rule “Weather” replace “When an Island Sets the Weather” with “When an Island or Gaia, Sets the Weather”

In the rule “Turns” replace “Generate and set the Weather” with “Set the Weather”

The Weather for Round 3 was Rainstorm. The weather for Rounds 4 and 5 were both Pleasant.

So technically, due to not being an Island, Josh wasn’t able to set the weather.

If he had Set the Weather, for round 5, he should’ve excluded Pleasant from the list of options.

Because turns have already been taken, trying to undo stuff is a bit of a mess. So because we already have to go “Josh set the weather even though that isn’t technically a thing he can do because its only defined for Islands” lets just handwave everything to have been okay, and just do things correctly starting in round 6.

Comments

Bais:

10-12-2020 02:59:24 UTC

Why is Josh not an Island?  “Each Dynasty may be headed by a single Island, known as the Gaia”

Bais:

10-12-2020 03:01:33 UTC

I don’t see what this CfJ does more than the other one

Bais:

10-12-2020 03:05:07 UTC

If anything, the issue is exactly the opposite:  Gaia is an island;  why doesn’t it have an entry in the Great Sea, then?  Did we skip all of Gaia’s turns..???

Clucky: ABBOT HE/HIM

10-12-2020 03:07:51 UTC

Dynastic Distance [Active]

For the purposes of dynastic rules which do not deal with voting, the Gaia is not a Island.

Bais:

10-12-2020 03:16:21 UTC

right you are

Bais:

10-12-2020 07:05:13 UTC

for

Kevan: HE/HIM

10-12-2020 09:03:03 UTC

for

Raven1207: HE/HIM

10-12-2020 12:41:52 UTC

for

Josh: HE/HIM

10-12-2020 14:23:39 UTC

for

derrick: HE/HIM

10-12-2020 14:37:53 UTC

for

derrick: HE/HIM

10-12-2020 14:38:32 UTC

We need a cleaner version of dynastic distance that lets the emperor do actions that don’t relate to them having a game state

pokes:

10-12-2020 14:55:34 UTC

for