Call for Judgment: Who says I cant?
Quorumed -Darth
Adminned at 26 Jan 2009 19:21:17 UTC
Rule 2.4 says
There exists a wiki document titled “Ingredients†which may be only modified as the Ruleset permits, and that is formatted as a list, known itself as the Ingredient List. As a daily action, a Staff Member may add one kind of edible ingredient to the end of the Ingredient List.
Nothing says that I cannot add past 50. It just says it isn’t allowed to have past 50. There are a number of ways this could be interpreted, but as it was perfectly legal to add my ingredient
Add Rice to the ingredient list. Give Clucky one guess.
On a related note, Rolden failed at actually reverting any changes other than the guess. That is what we call sloppy. I can’t revert back with the CfJ, because someone might not revert in the first place, but I also should have my ingredients back in my bowl and my credit for the rice back, even if this fails.
“At no time shall there exist more that 50 Ingredients on the Ingredient List.”
Qwazukee:
Let me get this straight. So you added it, but legally, it was not on this list because the list could not have 50 items? I interpret this as “the item was added, but was never on the list,” so