Friday, January 08, 2010

Proposal: Wish Queue Try Again

Passes 11-6. Josh

Adminned at 10 Jan 2010 14:23:35 UTC

In Rule 2.4 after the sentence:

The Djinni is unable to grant any Wishes or Boons while he is inside the Lamp.

Add another sentence which says:

Any wish made when the Djinni is inside the Lamp will be automatically denied.

Append the following paragraph to the end of Rule 2.4:

The Djinni’s Location cannot be changed to the Lamp if the Djinni was Freed by an Adventurer within the last 24 hours.

Prevent the scam by forcing the Djinni to stay outside the Lamp for at least 24 hours.

Comments

Kevan: City he/him

08-01-2010 18:13:36 UTC

against That addition prevents the one scam direction I thought of, but I still can’t see any actual advantage in adding the restriction. What’s your thinking? Why is a backlog of wishes bad?

Klisz:

08-01-2010 18:42:00 UTC

for  This also prevents an infinite-wishes scam.

Josh: he/they

08-01-2010 18:45:06 UTC

against

yabbaguy:

08-01-2010 20:11:23 UTC

imperial

digibomber:

08-01-2010 20:25:26 UTC

‘Cause you are not supposed to be able to make wishes when the Djinni is in a lamp. It seems strange to keep sending wishes to the Djinni and he just grants them as soon as he comes out of the lamp.

NoOneImportant:

08-01-2010 20:29:12 UTC

imperial

I’m not sure about the scams this is “fixing”...

Darknight: he/him

08-01-2010 21:45:54 UTC

for I’ve already denied every wish sent to me since i got lamped on the same grounds. It’s not like ya rub the lamp and get an answering machine saying leave a wish and i’ll get back to you on it.

Apathetic Lizardman:

08-01-2010 23:07:26 UTC

against For the sake of not needing the rule.

tecslicer:

08-01-2010 23:54:39 UTC

for per Darth

alethiophile:

08-01-2010 23:59:52 UTC

against

Aquafraternally Yours:

09-01-2010 02:33:38 UTC

for Per Darknight and with the same argument I used during the last rendition of this proposal.

redtara: they/them

09-01-2010 02:45:47 UTC

Idle FOR.

Bucky:

09-01-2010 06:18:39 UTC

for

Ornithopter:

09-01-2010 11:26:06 UTC

imperial

ais523:

09-01-2010 14:54:18 UTC

imperial

Uvthenfuv:

09-01-2010 18:51:41 UTC

imperial

spikebrennan:

09-01-2010 23:50:33 UTC

against

Qwazukee:

10-01-2010 14:31:40 UTC

against