Monday, May 07, 2018

Proposal: You can’t be living and dead

Self Killed. Failed By Derrick

Adminned at 08 May 2018 13:30:56 UTC

Change “Die (1 worth) Be dead at the end of the Story.” to

Die (1 worth) Be dead at the end of the Story.  This Goal cannot be used with Survive.

Change “Avenge an Enemy (1 worth) Targetting a single Sailor other than themselves: Have that Sailor be dead at the end of the Story.” to

Avenge an Enemy (1 worth) Targetting a single Sailor other than themselves: Have that Sailor be dead at the end of the Story.  This goal cannot be used if you are targeting the same person with “Protect a Friend”.

Okay, I hope I didn’t screw up anything THIS time…
Anyways, if a person picks 5 Avenge and 5 Protect, they could do nothing and have a guaranteed 5 worth.

Comments

Lulu: she/her

07-05-2018 02:29:37 UTC

Wait, I’m allowed to edit my proposal, right?

Axemabaro:

07-05-2018 02:36:22 UTC

Yes, if no-one comments yet for

Lulu: she/her

07-05-2018 03:04:54 UTC

Yeah, I realized I missed Stay Afloat/Abandon Ship.

card:

07-05-2018 04:34:27 UTC

for

Madrid:

07-05-2018 05:17:46 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

07-05-2018 07:10:05 UTC

What does “used” mean here - chosen or scored? Or both?

The flip side of a guaranteed 5 is that you’d never be able to score more than 5 either.

Madrid:

07-05-2018 11:00:12 UTC

Also, you can’t have multiple Survives/Dies because:

“including multiples of the same Goal so long as they all have Targets, and those Targets are different

Survive/Die have no Target. So you can only have one.

Lulu: she/her

07-05-2018 11:51:07 UTC

@Kevan By “used” I mean chosen.

derrick: he/him

07-05-2018 12:58:49 UTC

for

Thunder: he/him

07-05-2018 14:11:28 UTC

But arbitrage…
for

Madrid:

07-05-2018 14:20:40 UTC

I mean if we’re going for “lore” reasons it makes sense, I doubt you’d pray at night for your cabinmate to both survive and die.

Corona:

07-05-2018 15:04:25 UTC

for

Brendan: he/him

07-05-2018 15:09:02 UTC

against No reason not to be a dead man sailing.

Kevan: he/him

07-05-2018 15:25:46 UTC

[Cuddlebeam] I think if you come up with story reasons for wanting or benefitting from each outcome, they needn’t contradict - you enjoy the Cook’s breakfasts, but he’s also left you a fancy set of knives in his will.

Cpt_Koen:

07-05-2018 17:18:49 UTC

against

derrick: he/him

07-05-2018 17:37:54 UTC

against CoV

The maximum number of Worth is 10. This should keep everything in check.

card:

07-05-2018 17:49:18 UTC

against it would be fairly limiting on your points to do that

ElMarko:

07-05-2018 20:19:05 UTC

imperial

pokes:

07-05-2018 20:54:59 UTC

against agreed w/ derrick, the 10 Worth should keep this in check.

Lulu: she/her

08-05-2018 02:30:24 UTC

against

Kevan: he/him

08-05-2018 07:17:52 UTC

against