This needs to say that Reviews are flavour text, or otherwise make them unable to reinterpret rules.

I’m also wondering whether having them on the main tracking page might get unwieldy after a while – one possibility would be to put them in blog posts.

Ah, I’ll edit that!
My idea with having them on the main page is that, at least for me, it’s easy to miss Story Posts- if they do get unwieldy, perhaps someone could then propose a rule to move them to a separate page?

Yes, we’ll always be able to move them later, and I’m not yet sure where the best place to put them is, so we may as well do it on the tracking page until they need to go elsewhere.

While part of me is trepidatious about the interpretation of ‘genuine’ I think this looks good to me.

Fortunately the meaning of “should” means that any debate about “genuine” won’t cause gamestate damage.