Thursday, June 30, 2011

Proposal: A thin anti-sockpuppet coating.

self-killed -coppro

Adminned at 01 Jul 2011 17:14:59 UTC

Add the following text to the end of the Core Rule “Farmers” (or Rule 1.2 if no rule named “Farmers” exists):

A single person cannot control more than one non-Idle Farmer and should not control more than one Farmer at all (regardless of idleness). If a person controlling a non-Idle Farmer somehow takes control of another non-Idle Farmer, both Farmers become Idle.

Comments

ais523:

30-06-2011 17:50:37 UTC

This contradicts my understanding of how the rules work. A Farmer is an actual person, and what does it mean for a person to control another? You might want something along the lines of “A Farmer may not have more than one BlogNomic account. If a Farmer ever somehow ends up with more than one BlogNomic account, they should contact an Administrator to have one of the accounts deleted.”

Yoda:

30-06-2011 18:13:36 UTC

against Doesn’t this rule do the same thing? “A single person should not control more than one Farmer within BlogNomic.”

Bucky:

30-06-2011 19:53:42 UTC

This expands the fair play rules by making sockpuppeting strictly illegal rather than just a bannable offense.  In particular, this proposal would keep someone from making so many sockpuppets that they can vote down a CfJ banning them.

Yoda:

30-06-2011 20:52:54 UTC

for Ok, I can see that.  That would be a very hard scam to counter.

mideg:

30-06-2011 21:24:39 UTC

for

redtara: they/them

30-06-2011 21:35:46 UTC

for
However, our definition of “control” is a little ambiguous - if I tell a player to perform certain actions and he does, am I controlling him?

ais523:

30-06-2011 21:55:37 UTC

against I don’t think the resulting rule would do what it seems to do. In particular, if I register ten accounts on BlogNomic and vote FOR with all of them, that’s one vote FOR because a Farmer cannot vote more than once and have them all count, no matter what it looks like on the blog.

mideg:

30-06-2011 21:57:40 UTC

But is a Farmer defined as a person in real life or as an account?

Bucky:

30-06-2011 22:07:21 UTC

against S-K per Ienpw.  I do not want this misinterpreted in a way that would disrupt the dynasty by idling Yoda (and/or Galtori)

Oranjer:

01-07-2011 20:35:37 UTC

for (just a test)