Saturday, July 09, 2011

Call for Judgment: Action Dispute

0-11 is a quorum against. Failed.

Adminned at 09 Jul 2011 22:05:09 UTC

GNDT referenced in this CfJ:

  aguydude’s Status = Fighting (was Resting)
(Entering the Arena.)

  aguydude’s Status = Fighting (was Fighting)
(Shoving Blacky)

  aguydude’s AP = 1 (was 3)
(Shoving Blacky)

  aguydude’s AP = 3 (was 1)
(Refreshing.)

  aguydude’s AP = 2 (was 3)
(Stepping)

  aguydude’s AP = 0 (was 2)
(Aguydude Shoves Blacky Again. Aguydude is Glad Shoving is not a Main Action)

  aguydude’s AP = 0 (was 0)
(Black has triggered a trap:  DICE6:4 )

  aguydude’s Frags = 1
(Blacky Has been killed.)

  Blacky’s Status = Resting (was Fighting)

  Comment:
(I should’ve moved to B6. Oh well, I guess I’m spreading the love by leaving myself open to the same trick I used myself.)
09/07 06:39 (UTC) - coppro
  Comment:
(Let’s lay a trap:  DICE9:2   DICE9:7 )
09/07 06:47 (UTC) - SingularByte
  aguydude’s AP = 1 (was 0)
(Illegal, see rule 2.3.1)

  aguydude’s Frags = 0 (was 1)
(Illegal, see rule 2.3.1)

If this CfJ passes, increase Aguydude’s Frags by 1.

Explanation: Shoving does not count as a main action, so Shoving does not force a refresh.  Further, players may spend more than 3 main AP within 24 hours, as 2.3.1 disallows 3 Main Actions, not 3 AP spent.  I’m not clear on what SingularByte is disagreeing with: I did mention this scam in a proposal, which Singularbyte read and responded to.

Comments

aguydude:

07-09-2011 18:25:14 UTC

against Oops, Just saw in the GNDT that SingularByte reverted his change.  Everyone should probably vote against this.  Sorry.

Bucky:

07-09-2011 18:30:48 UTC

against

Kevan:

07-09-2011 18:32:08 UTC

against

Out of interest, can non-admin players delete their own posts if they want to, or does the blog engine not let them? (“If no Gladiator has commented on it, an official post may be altered or removed by its author.”)

aguydude:

07-09-2011 18:34:19 UTC

I’m not confident enough in my understanding of the ruleset take advantage of most of those cleanup rules.

Ely:

07-09-2011 18:53:44 UTC

against

SingularByte:

07-09-2011 19:38:11 UTC

against I admit I didn’t fully think it through before reverting.

Yoda:

07-09-2011 21:08:13 UTC

against

Blacky:

07-09-2011 21:12:54 UTC

for You killed me! Pöhhh…
against

Darknight:

07-09-2011 21:35:25 UTC

against

mideg:

07-09-2011 21:37:27 UTC

against

Winner:

07-09-2011 21:41:51 UTC

against

Galtori:

07-10-2011 03:49:54 UTC

against