Sunday, April 24, 2022

Proposal: Basic Atlantean Grammar

Timed out and enacted,, 8-0. Josh

Adminned at 26 Apr 2022 19:11:36 UTC

Add the following as a new rule to the ruleset, called Precious :

Each Memory of Atlantis has an amount of , which is publicly tracked and defaults to .

Once every , a Memory of Atlantis may their by 2.

Add , , and to the list of tracked Atlantean Elements.



24-04-2022 21:58:02 UTC

It is intentional that the “star” means both a value that “swirl” can take and also some indeterminate duration of time? (Once every “star”...)

Does “tracked Atlantean Element” mean the same thing as “Atlantean Element”? All Atlantean Elements are part of gamestate and should be tracked, right?

So when the proposal says to add the “star” twice to the list of tracked Atlantean Elements, is the real effect on gamestate just that the star becomes an Atlantean Element (once)?

wdtefv: hu/hum

24-04-2022 22:57:06 UTC



25-04-2022 00:19:49 UTC



25-04-2022 00:42:18 UTC

I’m not sure what it means, but that’s the game.


25-04-2022 03:48:28 UTC

Why is the star on there twice? It’s the same exact image. imperial


25-04-2022 03:49:56 UTC

Also, couldn’t you add them to the list of Elements yourself, without a proposal?

SingularByte: he/him

25-04-2022 05:07:47 UTC


SingularByte: he/him

25-04-2022 05:36:13 UTC

I must admit though, I’m very curious how these implied definitions fit in with my triangular rules that are in the ruleset.

Josh: he/they

25-04-2022 09:09:08 UTC

This might be a cheeky use of the edit-typo option but I’ve edited the second start symbol (element2.png) into what it should have been (elements.png).

SingularByte me too!

Raven1207: he/him

25-04-2022 11:30:43 UTC



25-04-2022 12:02:56 UTC

Josh I don’t think that counts as an obvious typo


25-04-2022 12:13:21 UTC

I agree; I want to let it pass but I don’t think we should set that precedent. Maybe a CfJ?

SingularByte: he/him

25-04-2022 13:27:50 UTC

My gut feeling would be to declare it illegal and fail it, then have a cfj to override that and force it to pass. I can probably pick that up later today unless someone gets to it first.

SingularByte: he/him

25-04-2022 13:29:07 UTC

Or maybe just a second proposal instead of a cfj since the queue is empty other than this.


25-04-2022 20:35:51 UTC