Call for Judgment: Boardom
Makes no changes to the Gamestate or Ruleset. Josh
Adminned at 21 Feb 2022 18:06:23 UTC
Brendan set up the new round/game of tic tac toe incorrectly; it should be 6x6 rather than 7x7.
The rules on fixing AAs are a bit of a mess; the rule Atomic Actions says “If one or more steps of an Atomic Action were done incorrectly, the Player must redo the Atomic Action; for that purpose, the Player uses any legal steps that have already been completed in the illegal Atomic Action and only redoes the illegal ones” - which suggests that only Brendan can fix it. However, representations of the gamestate says “Alter the representation to match what they believe to be the correct application of an incorrectly-applied alteration. This may include completing incomplete actions on behalf of the original Player, if doing so would not require the correcting Player to make any decisions on behalf of the original Player”. Priority between the two clauses is a little unclear - arguably Brendan’s action isn’t incomplete, it’s incorrect. All of that could use fixing.
This isn’t going to fix anything, though; this just gets the game moving again.
Uphold Brendan’s reset action performed at 03:23, 20 February 2022, and assert that that action has been correctly completed; if Brendan has otherwise completed that action since the posting of this CfJ, then carry out no further action as in this enactment. Uphold my correction of that reset action, performed on 10:13, 20 February 2022, and any subsequent, otherwise legal play actions on that Grid. Uphold Clucky’s move on 07:44, 20 February 2022. This CfJ explicitly does not uphold my action of 07:56, 20 February 2022, which is to be resolved under a separate votable matter.
Lulu: she/her