Saturday, October 02, 2021

Call for Judgment: Broken Promises

Reached quorum 9 votes to 0. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 03 Oct 2021 12:44:41 UTC

Make any floors that are currently shorted out not shorted out.

Set the Breaker for Current A to B2, the Breaker for Current B to B7, the Breaker for Current C to B8.

Then, for current’s D-K, in order, set its Breaker to a random floor which is not already the Breaker for another Current. passed with flying colors, but it had a few problems.

First, it didn’t specify which Currents/Breakers I should be placing. Which I think means I might not have been able to actually set them.

Secondly, it uses the phrase “Place a Breaker” but while the intent is clear, I don’t think the rules actually outline what “placing a breaker” does.

Finally, “Place each remaining breaker on a randomly chosen Floor that does not have a breaker.” arguably, if it did anything, would’ve placed all the other breakers on the same randomly chosen floor instantly shorting it out. Which I don’t think was the intent, and was saved just by the fact that Breakers can’t be placed.

So I think technically the proposal enactment did nothing, hence why I did nothing upon enactment, and this CfJ covers all the bases of what if actually the proposal did something else (like shorting out a random floor) and instead does what I believe the proposal meant to do—at the time of enactment, lemon was on B2, I was on B7 and Spyder was on B8. So those three get a breaker and everything else gets randomly applied to its own floor.



02-10-2021 04:05:52 UTC

for Sure.

Raven1207: he/him

02-10-2021 04:09:22 UTC


Josh: he/they

02-10-2021 08:46:56 UTC


Kevan: he/him

02-10-2021 10:10:19 UTC



02-10-2021 21:17:51 UTC


Zack: he/him

02-10-2021 22:06:09 UTC


lemon: she/her

03-10-2021 05:31:12 UTC



03-10-2021 09:51:29 UTC