Can we get a link to a specific version of the page, there? Maybe even at a different page title that doesn’t have a Josh victory scam in the edit history?

Ugh I knew I should have waited 5 years

There, are you happy now you monster

So the only thing this is negating in a non-trivial way is the Arsonist’s “Set the state of any building which is not secure to burned” - but what does that mean, given that this mechanic explicitly says it isn’t a revert and is instead “an opposite and neutralising effect”?

Can the Deputy change a Building from “burned” to any state other than secure, even if that’s not the state the Arsonist found it in?

Yeah, ‘opposite and neutralising effect’ is awkward phrasing that will need some degree of fixing - I couldn’t quite find the wording. If I feel inspired in the morning I’ll propose to fix.

Doesn’t this give every role only one role action? Might be a bit limiting.

Terrible unbalanceable dynasty idea: proposals are stored in wikipages which are freely editable; at the end of the voting period, whatever the text says gets enacted.

@Clucky Only to begin with, and pretty easy to modify

Would this scam have worked? Josh hasn’t remembered his role.

If a Sheriff sets a building from secure to public, and a Vandal sets it from public to tagged, can a Burglar still undo the Sheriff’s role action?

@ayesdeeef it was seeding - it was there so that, once we had a way of remembering our roles, I could just say “aha, but look” and win instantly on an apparently innocuous proposal.

@also ayesdeeef - the wording for counter actions needs revising, and that’s where my next proposal slot is going - I think it’s important that counters not revert the action that they’re countering, that they’re subsequent, dependent actions that simply have a neutralising effect, but I’ll need some time to figure out how to word that effectively.

Good point from Ayesdeeef about undoing. The Coup-style “role X blocks role Y” responses seem like they aren’t really going to work in an asynchronous game, where the blocker might not step in until a day or two later, after other actions have happened.

CoV.

This lacks a victory tag. I don’t think it could be used to achieve victory, even under the original scam.