Monday, July 28, 2025

Call for Judgment: Containing With

sending it down 2-8, chiiika.

Adminned at 29 Jul 2025 03:08:28 UTC

In the rule “The Night”, rewrite “with identical ingredients” into

with the same list of ingredients

I’m unsure if I am reading this right; but I was thinking about duplication and I was thinking about this line - hypothetically, if I have a Pork dish; does a dish with “Pork, Salad, Sauce” counts as “with identical ingredients” because the Pork is there?

Comments

Chiiika: she/her

28-07-2025 11:23:56 UTC

I feel like there’s some $19 dishes waiting to bite off those $20 single item dishes scam that is waiting to spring.

eternalservererror:

28-07-2025 13:05:45 UTC

Can you clarify why that would be a scam? Referring to $20 single item dishes.

arthexis: he/him

28-07-2025 13:15:09 UTC

for

eternalservererror:

28-07-2025 13:16:16 UTC

nevermind, i follow what you’re saying now

Kevan: Yard he/him

28-07-2025 13:30:49 UTC

The fuller quote from the rule is “If any Dishes with identical ingredients as the Choice are available…”

My reading would be that no, a Dish of “Pork, Salad, Sauce” did not have identical ingredients to a Dish of “Pork”. The ingredients differ.

This change of wording may weaken it in another direction by considering the sequence of the list to matter: is “Pork, Salad, Sauce” the same list as “Sauce, Pork, Salad”?

JonathanDark: he/him

28-07-2025 13:31:52 UTC

Based on Kevan’s reading, this seems like a non-issue.  against

Josh: he/they

28-07-2025 15:09:49 UTC

against

eternalservererror:

28-07-2025 16:48:29 UTC

against

Kevan: Yard he/him

28-07-2025 16:59:58 UTC

against

Darknight: he/him

28-07-2025 17:25:06 UTC

against

Desertfrog:

28-07-2025 18:45:34 UTC

against

DoomedIdeas: he/him

28-07-2025 20:58:06 UTC

against

aria: she/they

28-07-2025 21:38:40 UTC

against