I’m not a huge fan of the way this assigns new products to animals, but the only one that entirely breaks things is religious. Once you have a religious animal, there is no need for any other type of animal, and thats not a good thing.

I’d prefer if the Psyche simply got the existing product more efficiently, or gave a way to get a product even if you’ve found nothing productive.

OK, Religious removed!

I also don’t feel like this dynasty has a significant eldritch component right now. Maybe if it was Unknowable or Alien, and giving it a random Product would result in receiving a random Product in return?

Ah, my intent was that their psyche was inescrutable, confusing and opaque as per the plain use of that adjective, not Lovecraftian.

The base idea is fine, but the ability to milk every single animal we come across is a little silly.

[derrick] Surely one in four of them, at most? And in practice we might not be able to roll five different Effects for each Animal.