Monday, November 17, 2014

Proposal: I fail, too

Passes 5-0 with quorum FOR. -Bucky

Adminned at 19 Nov 2014 05:19:27 UTC

In the rule “List of Proxies”, change the text

McDefense to randomly choose Defense or Midfield player

to

McDefense to randomly choose a Defense or Midfield player, other than itself,

Comments

Sprucial:

17-11-2014 03:56:50 UTC

for

ayesdeeef:

17-11-2014 17:53:05 UTC

In an earlier comment, E said “I took ‘If no Player has the Ball, it is considered Out of Play” to be a definition of “Out of Play’.” That post has since closed, so I am responding to the implied question here: according to the above quote, no player having the ball causes it to be considered out of play. However, the ball being out of play does not mean that no player should have the ball. These two implications are distinct statements with different meanings.

Here is an analogy: Staying up past bedtime causes tiredness. While this statement may be true, the fact that I am tired does not necessarily mean that I stayed up past bedtime. Keyword necessarily. for

Sylphrena:

18-11-2014 03:01:34 UTC

for &ayesdeeef;: yeah, that’s why I wanted to change it back in the original definition but by the time I did it was kind of pointless.

Eritivus:

18-11-2014 14:42:30 UTC

for