Tuesday, June 07, 2011

Call for Judgment: Is Replacing a Crop Destroying It?

has no effect.—Yoda

Adminned at 07 Jun 2011 07:53:52 UTC

For context, I quote the GNDT:

07/06 08:30 (UTC) - Ely
  SingularByte’s Sun = 155 (was 145)
(You “replace” the Crop, not destroy. CfJ if you don’t agree)

  SingularByte’s Wood = 0 (was 20)
(You “replace” the Crop, not destroy. CfJ if you don’t agree)

Well, I disagree.  My reason is found in Storage Space:

A crop is destroyed whenever it is removed from their plot, except if a rule states otherwise.

Replacing a crop means the previous crop is no longer on the plot, and thus has been removed from the plot.

posted by aguydude at 07 Jun 2011 08:33:51 UTC Comments (5)

Comments

Ely:

07-06-2011 08:55:58 UTC

for My bad, I read that rule too fast. Kick me.
By the way, this CfJ has no gamestate effect, so it may be failed. I’ll revert the reverting. :P

Ely:

07-06-2011 08:56:29 UTC

Oh, and I’m off planting cabbage, if someone asks for me.

mideg:

07-06-2011 09:41:08 UTC

for as a symbolic vote.

aguydude:

07-06-2011 11:47:33 UTC

Ely: Well, all I would’ve had as gamestate effect would’ve been for your revert to be reverted, so meh.

Yoda:

07-06-2011 14:53:29 UTC

for for the record, but I’ll go ahead and fail it according to rule 1.7: “Any CfJ that has no effect on the ruleset or gamestate may be automatically failed by any admin.”