Tuesday, April 07, 2015

Proposal: Know your enemy

Enacted 6-0, with two unresolved DEFs. Josh

Adminned at 09 Apr 2015 06:46:00 UTC

Create a new rule, “The Reviewers”:

There are five Reviewers:
-Antonio Fusilli
-Bruce Haggis
-Chiaki Ramen
-Dominique Labaguette
-Esmeralda Paella
Each Reviewer has a Sweet Spot for each of the existing Valued Properties. A Sweet Spot is an integer comprised between 0 and 10 included. Each Reviewer may be Vegetarian. Each Reviewer has one Favourite Ingredient, which is one of the Ingredients listed in rule Ingredients. All the characteristics of the Reviewers (Sweet Spots, Vegetarianism, Favourite Ingredient) are fixed and they shall be kept track of by the Restaurant Manager, who should reveal them only when allowed by the Ruleset.
If one or more of a Reviewer’s characteristics has not been determined yet, the Restaurant Manager may and should privately determine it using a method of their choice.

Create a new rule, “Fame”:

Each Cook has a “References” field, tracked as a string in the GNDT, consisting in the first letters of the names of the Reviewers that have ever awarded that Cook a 5-star rating.

Create a new rule, “Opening Soon!”:

The Restaurant Manager may not post Reviews.

Comments

Kevan:

04-07-2015 12:14:48 UTC

for

severian:

04-07-2015 12:58:04 UTC

for

Darknight:

04-07-2015 14:29:23 UTC

for

Josh:

04-07-2015 14:41:22 UTC

imperial

Brendan:

04-07-2015 15:26:06 UTC

for

Sylphrena:

04-07-2015 16:18:40 UTC

for

mideg:

04-07-2015 16:59:32 UTC

imperial If this is enacted, how do we handle the existing Review?

Ely:

04-07-2015 17:06:45 UTC

Well, it was legal at the time of its posting, so it should be ok.
Before we open the restaurant we can add a clause to the rules so that you never have to resolve it.

Sylphrena:

04-07-2015 17:22:22 UTC

Although currently there is no such thing as a “five-star rating”. “A rating is an Integer value that can be positive, negative or 0.” No stars are mentioned.

Ely:

04-07-2015 17:33:00 UTC

Sylphrena: that was intentional, to avoid people getting References before some arrangements are done. The current rating system needs to be fixed anyway, I think.