Monday, October 15, 2007

Proposal: Ly-Can’t-thropy

Failed by Kevan; self-killed.

This proposal was illegally failed by Chivalrybean some time before this, but it wasn’t the oldest proposal in the queue, at the time.

Adminned at 16 Oct 2007 01:08:30 UTC

If the proposal Werewolf fails, this proposal does nothing.

In the rule Werewolves, change the text

If all living Werewolves have the same target, if they have not yet killed that day, and if the target is still Alive, then the Mayor may post a blog entry announcing that their target has been murdered. That Villager is now Dead.

to

If all living Werewolves have the same target, if they have not yet killed that day, and if the target is still Alive, then the Mayor may roll a 1DICE100 in the GNDT. If the result is 11-100, the mayor maypost a blog entry announcing that their target has been murdered. That Villager is now Dead. If the result is 1-10, the Villager escapes death with a clue. The clue is one random letter from the werewolf’s name. The clue shall be delivered to the still alive villager secretly via e-mail or some similer means.

Comments

Hix:

15-10-2007 20:23:33 UTC

against If there is a kill failure chance (and I think there should be), it should not be determined by a publicly viewable roll in the GNDT.  The werewolves should have to wonder whether they were uncoordinated, or simply had bad luck.

Also, who is this “the werewolf” being referenced in “The clue is one random letter from the werewolf’s name”??

Chivalrybean:

15-10-2007 20:26:14 UTC

hmm… good points.

I meant to make ‘the werewolf’ be a random werewolf that was included in the kill attempt. (but worded better)

Kevan: he/him

15-10-2007 20:39:58 UTC

against As Hix. Might be better to have the clue as “a list of quorum/2 random villagers, including one werewolf”, as well, so as not to make name-choice a factor. (Hix would be in trouble on an “x”.)

spikebrennan:

15-10-2007 20:47:18 UTC

against per hix

Chivalrybean:

15-10-2007 21:05:57 UTC

What about the random chance of kill failure? What’s a good way for that to be decided?

Hix:

15-10-2007 22:13:15 UTC

Same way we randomly decide who is or isn’t a werewolf should suffice.

Chivalrybean:

15-10-2007 22:14:13 UTC

against

Works for me. SK.