Tuesday, August 25, 2015

Proposal: Miscellaneous Actions

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 27 Aug 2015 07:37:13 UTC

Add a new Rule to the Ruleset, entitled Miscellaneous Actions, with the following text:

A Prisoner may, as a daily action, Give Junk. This stands for decreasing their own Junk by 1, then increasing the Junk of any other Prisoner by 1.

A Prisoner with a RI less than 1 may, as a weekly action, Behave Well. This stands for decreasing their own Sentence by 1 year.

A Prisoner with a RI greater than 1 may, as a weekly action, Behave Bad. This stands for increasing their own Sentence by 1 year.

 

Comments

Lynx:

08-25-2015 19:31:33 UTC

for

ShareDVI:

08-25-2015 20:38:54 UTC

against I don’t like decreasing sentence for free, even once per week. Especially because Withdrawn can make RI=0.9, if he wants.

What will happen if the sentence is already zero?

What if RI=1?

Wouldn’t it be logical to change RI somehow as a result of Behaving Good/Bad?

Oh, I know! Maybe, RI shoud be calculated from cooperation/defection rate somehow.

Josh: HE/HIM

08-25-2015 20:50:45 UTC

FYI, Lynx, you don’t have to vote for your own proposals - as the author you have an implicit FOR.

for

Lynx:

08-26-2015 01:21:46 UTC

I usually vote FOR in order to be notified by e-mail of new comments.

Kevan: HE/HIM

08-26-2015 07:53:27 UTC

against

Purplebeard:

08-26-2015 18:41:01 UTC

against

Purplebeard:

08-26-2015 18:42:45 UTC

This proposal could have used a “If the proposal named blah failed, this does nothing” clause.

Lynx:

08-27-2015 00:33:27 UTC

against